Although there is a site where you can buy printed alligator party ware, I decided to try and make many elements on my own. Here are the favor bags. They contain a small bag of green licorice (purchased at Dollar Tree -- renamed as "Alligator tails"), a pencil, a homemade notebook, and a cute little coin purse (a splurge at $2 each).
I then made little felt alligator clips using clothespins to hold the bags shut, and added a sticker on the bag that says "See you later."
I may make name tags to clip onto the bags. With favors, I always seem to face the dilemma that a) nobody takes said favors, or b) I have them labelled and end up being stalker weirdo for a couple months as I carry favor bags around delivering them at various events.
I also made some foam visors to look like alligators. I had to cut the foam teeth by hand, but found foam eyes online, which saved some time. Hank says I have to make a sign warning people that the alligator hats may bite. Indeed, the spiral cord does have a tendency to get caught in your hair...
Favorite of the day: Popcorn monster favors
Working on: More party prep